Commission only worker entitled to claim 13 years’ worth of holiday pay

22nd February 2018

Commission only worker entitled to claim 13 years’ worth of holiday pay

Avoiding risk of legal action with right job labels

Share this article

At the end of last year whilst UK newspapers were busy rejoicing about Prince Harry having finally popped the question, the European Court of Justice delivered yet another blow to UK employers which should have a far greater impact on them than the royal wedding. The court found that Mr King, a commission only sales person who had refused a contract of employment a few years prior, was entitled to claim 13 years’ worth of holiday pay.

Worker’s rights is a very trendy topic in UK employment law, with big names such as Uber discovering that their people were workers and had employment rights. The Sash Window Workshop Ltd, who now face the consequences of an ECJ decision going against them, is not a big name; it is a small Berkshire based company. It is an SME like the majority of my clients.

A worker is not quite an employee, but someone whom the legislator believes is worthy of some employment law protection, the main one being holiday pay. Holiday pay claims are often perceived as representing a small risk compared to claims of unfair dismissal or discrimination where damages are based on loss of earnings.

The UK government has tried to protect employers against large back pay claims by introducing the Deduction from Wages (Limitation) Regulations 2014, only allowing a back pay to go back two years. The Employment Appeals Tribunal in Bear Scotland v Fulton had put another barrier to substantial holiday pay claims, in deciding that any three month gap between instances of unpaid (or underpaid) holiday pay will break a series of deductions. Both these rules are likely to be contrary to the ECJ decision in King v the Sash Windows Workshop Ltd at least in situations where the worker was not unable to take holiday pay because of a long term sickness but deterred from taking holiday because he would not be paid for it.

The ECJ decision makes holiday pay claims much more of a risk for any employer. Holiday pay claims brought by wrongly labelled self-employed people could span over many years. Furthermore, those people are often hired under a standard contract. If one wrongly labelled self-employed person wins their claim, it will be very easy for all other self-employed hired under the same contract to claim their rights.

For more about workers’ status see:


For more on holiday pay see:



If you are at all concerned about your freelancers (or anyone else working for you in a non-employed capacity) please contact us for a free chat.

With over 20 years of experience advising Small and Medium Businesses from our offices in London and Scotland, you can confidentially speak to one of our specialist employment lawyers at any time. Call us on 0333 939 8741, or email us at

We hope you find this update useful. This blog does not constitute legal advice on any particular situation you may have.

© Employease: The Employment Practice Ltd 2017




Company registered in England Reg No: 2931940

Registered Office: 40 Woodford Avenue, Gants Hill, Essex IG2 6XQ

Share this article

Related Articles

Coronavirus Job Retention Scheme Update

31st March 2020

We now have some clarifications from HM Government on the Coronavirus Job Retention Scheme (CJRS) for both employers and employees. Some important questions have been answered, but not all. We’ll present that guidance below as a Q&A to make it easier to find the information you need as quickly as possible. We urge you to […]

Covid-19 Self Employment Income Support Scheme

27th March 2020

There are around five million self-employed workers in the UK who did not benefit from the Coronavirus Job Retention Scheme. In less than a week after the Job Retention Scheme was announced, the government has put a package together to support the self-employed, after much lobbying on their behalf. According to the HMRC web-site, the […]

Coronavirus Job Retention Scheme

23rd March 2020

We have been blogging about the impact of Coronavirus over the past two weeks. You can find our most recent blog here. On Friday 20th March 2020, the government announced a scheme called the Coronavirus Job Retention Scheme, under which all UK employers will be able to access support to continue paying part of their employees’ salary for those […]